Tucked away in the quiet countryside of Frederick County, Maryland, lies the tiny, seemingly peaceful town of Burkittsville. Blink and you’ll miss it — a scattering of old houses, a small church, and rolling green hills that whisper with history. But behind that postcard-perfect scenery lurks one of the darkest legends in America — a story of witchcraft, curses, and mysterious deaths that have haunted Maryland for over two centuries.
Locals say you can still feel her presence if you step too deep into the Black Hills Forest on a moonless night. They say she watches from the shadows… waiting.
The Witch of Blair: A Legend is Born
Long before the world knew Burkittsville by name, there was another settlement here — a small colonial town called Blair. And in 1785, a woman named Elly Kedward was accused of doing something unspeakable.
Children claimed Elly had lured them into the woods to take their blood — a horrifying accusation in a time already gripped by witch hysteria. The townsfolk wasted no time. They tied her to a tree deep in the forest and left her there to freeze to death in the bitter Maryland winter.
But the story doesn’t end there.
By the following year, every child who accused Elly Kedward vanished. Soon after, the rest of the townspeople fled Blair, terrified that they’d been cursed. No one dared return. For decades, the land lay silent — until a new town was founded on its ashes in 1824. That town was Burkittsville.
The Curse Returns
If the legend had ended there, it might have faded into obscurity — but the darkness in Burkittsville never seemed to stay buried for long.
In 1825, just one year after the new town was established, tragedy struck. A ten-year-old girl named Eileen Treacle was playing near Tappy East Creek when a pale hand supposedly reached from the water, pulled her under, and vanished. Eleven people claimed to see it happen. Her body was never recovered.
For thirteen days afterward, the creek was clogged with oily, stick-like debris. Locals whispered that Elly Kedward’s spirit had claimed another victim.
Coffin Rock: The Gruesome Discovery
Fast forward to 1886. An eight-year-old boy named Robin Weaver went missing in the forest. Search parties were formed, and while Robin eventually returned home unharmed, one of the search teams never came back.
Weeks later, a second search party stumbled upon a nightmare at Coffin Rock — the missing men had been ritually disemboweled, their bodies tied together in a strange symbol. Horrified, the rescuers ran for help. When they returned with others… the bodies were gone. Only the blood-stained rocks remained.
Was it wild animals? A madman in the woods? Or the restless spirit of the witch they had left to die over a century before?
The Burkittsville Murders
Then came the 1940s — and with them, a series of disappearances that would forever cement Burkittsville’s reputation as one of America’s most haunted places.
Between November 1940 and May 1941, eight children vanished without a trace. Six months later, a reclusive hermit named Rustin Parr walked into a Burkittsville grocery store and said only:
“I’m finally finished.”
Police followed Parr to his cabin deep in the Black Hills Forest, where they made a horrifying discovery: the bodies of seven missing children, each murdered in what looked like ritual sacrifices. Parr confessed to everything, claiming he had acted under the command of “an old woman who lived in the woods.”
He was hanged for his crimes — but even as the rope tightened, Parr swore he was not alone out there.
Myth or Marketing? The Blair Witch Project
Then came 1999.
When The Blair Witch Project hit theaters, it shattered box office records — and terrified audiences worldwide. Marketed as a “found footage” film, it followed three student filmmakers — Heather, Josh, and Mike — who vanished in the Black Hills Forest while investigating the Blair Witch legend.
The film’s shaky handheld camera work and eerie realism made it feel real. Missing-person posters circulated online. A fake documentary aired on TV. Viewers were convinced it was all true — that the footage had been discovered after the students’ disappearance.
Of course, it wasn’t. The actors were alive and well. But the legend had come to life once more. Burkittsville became a pilgrimage site for horror fans, ghost hunters, and paranormal investigators alike.
The Real Town of Burkittsville
Today, Burkittsville is a quiet, tiny community of just a few hundred residents — but the shadow of the Blair Witch still lingers. Visitors come searching for haunted trails, mysterious symbols, and the ruins of Rustin Parr’s cabin (which never actually existed).
Locals have mixed feelings. Some embrace the fame. Others wish the town could shed its ghostly reputation. Signs have been stolen, cemeteries trespassed, and curiosity seekers wander the woods hoping to glimpse the supernatural.
But the strangest part? Every now and then, someone reports hearing whispers in the trees near the edge of town…
So, Is the Blair Witch Real?
There are no historical records of Elly Kedward, Rustin Parr, or any ritualistic murders in Maryland’s archives. The stories, dates, and deaths all belong to a carefully constructed mythology — one that brilliantly blurred the line between horror and history.
Yet legends have power for a reason. They come from somewhere — from fears passed down, from forgotten truths, from the way shadows stretch longer when we tell stories around a fire.
Maybe there never was a witch in Burkittsville.
Maybe there’s just something about those woods that remembers.
If You Dare to Visit…
Burkittsville still stands, small and silent, beneath the rolling Maryland hills. The forest is still there too — tall, dark, and whispering with every gust of wind.
If you ever find yourself walking its trails, stop for a moment. Listen closely. You might hear nothing at all. Or you might hear the faint sound of a woman weeping in the distance…
And if you do — don’t look back.
Thanks for reading! 
If you love haunted tales and paranormal mysteries, please do follow Hauntic on Facebook and subscribe to our Youtube channel.
— Lauren Campbell, Hauntic.com Contributor 
